RealGM Football: The Red Zone - Be An NFL GM Semifinals: Brady Vs. Manning

	More from RealGM NBA: Benign Growth Removed From White's Jaw MLB: Giants To Talk Trade With Twins For Delmon Young? NHL: Sundin Still Hasn't Started Training
Index News Scores & Statistics Draft Simulator Team Columns Transactions NFL Forum

The Red Zone

Red Zone Archives

8th Oct, 2008
Teams With Two-RB's Win More Often Than Those With A Featured Back

7th Oct, 2008
KQ: Champs Roll Without Plax

Full Archive

NFL Columns

RealGM Poll

Which NFC East team is least likely to make the playoffs?

Eagles
Cowboys
Redskins
Giants

Poll Archives

Draft Sim ID

Sponsors

Don't miss your chance for football betting at BetUS.com. As America's #1 sportsbook, BetUS offers the most up-to-date betting lines & odds for all your betting needs.

Be An NFL GM Semifinals: Brady Vs. Manning

Authored by Andrew Perna - 1st September, 2006 - 4:04 pm

Current Featured Columns

The New Parity Of College Football

Between 2002 and 2006, each school that came into the season ranked No. 1 in the nation ran the table in the regular season, but we've seen huge turnover in 07 and 08.

Christopher Reina. 14th October, 2008.

Rules Of Thumb, Fantasy Football Edition

Jeff Risdon was actually into fantasy football back in the early 90s, and he quite a bit to say about how it has changed over the years and infiltrated the mainstream.

Jeff Risdon. 13th October, 2008.

Redskins On The Rise

This season, the Redskins take it slow, build from within direction they took while led by Joe Gibbs is taking the next step.

Randolph Charlotin. 2nd October, 2008.

Go Slow With Flacco

Baltimore wants Flacco to be their QB of the future. But the Ravens feel they have no choice but to start him now because Boller and Smith are unavailable. Wrong!

Randolph Charlotin. 3rd September, 2008.

RealGM Search

In the first of two final four match-ups New England’s Tom Brady will take on Indianapolis’s Peyton Manning for the chance to represent the AFC in the finals of our ‘Be an NFL GM’ contest. Brady has three Super Bowl rings, while Peyton is arguably the most talented quarterback of his era. You might want to keep in mind that if Peyton wins, and his brother Eli outlasts Reggie Bush, the our RealGM Franchise Player of the Year would be decided in a Manning vs. Manning Super Bowl later next week!

The Case for Brady

If you want a quarterback to build a franchise on, Brady has to be at the top of your list. Unlike a lot of his NFL counterparts, he always plays within himself and makes excellent decisions when they are needed most. In addition to his three Super Bowl rings, Brady is only getting better as a quarterback. He had his best statistical season in 2005, throwing for 4,110 yards and twenty-six touchdowns.

The Case against Brady

Many people in the sporting world feel that Brady is the best quarterback in the entire league. While it may be true, Brady’s far from the most talented field general in the game of football. He doesn’t have the smarts of Peyton Manning, the legs of Michael Vick, or the arm strength of John Elway. It hasn’t caught up with him yet, but as he gets older, it might become a problem for him, as it did for Joe Montana when he was forced out of San Francisco by the emerging Steve Young.

The Case for Peyton

If you’re looking for a quarterback whose head is 110% into the game of football, Manning is your man. Peyton is the best pure quarterback in all of football, and he’s still only a season removed from breaking Dan Marino’s single-season touchdown record. He’s the smartest quarterback on the field, and you can never doubt that he’s giving his all to will his team to victory. He also makes some pretty funny commercials.

The Case against Peyton

The only real case you can make against Peyton is that he has difficulty winning in the ‘big game.’ As great as he has been in his nine-year career he’s yet to make a trip to the Super Bowl and he’s not getting any younger, which is something an opponent like Brady has over him. Manning can also tend to over think things on the football field, particularly when he’s blitzed. He reads a defense like no other before the snap, but sometimes he thinks too much and doesn’t feel the game.

The choice is yours – Who will make it to the RealGM Super Bowl?

Vote on our NFL main page to have your voice heard!

Also, submit your daily choice to Andrew.Perna@realgm.com in order to enter yourself in the running for a Mitchell & Ness Retro NFL Jersey from DistantReplays.com (a $300 value!).

More from RealGM